Utterly Meaningless » Blog Archive » THAT DAMN ACLU
  • THAT DAMN ACLU

    Filed at 4:28 pm under by dcobranchi

    Always sticking its nose in where it doesn’t belong.

    KANSAS CITY, Missouri (Reuters) – A Missouri couple who must get married, or move, in order to comply with a housing ordinance in Black Jack, Missouri, sued the town on Thursday, claiming rules prohibiting the unmarried couple and their children from living together are unconstitutional.

    The petition, filed in the Circuit Court of St. Louis County, challenges a Black Jack city ordinance that prohibits more than three people from living together in the same house if they are unrelated by blood, marriage or adoption.

    …Shelltrack and Loving have lived together about 13 years and have two children together, along with a 15-year-old daughter of Shelltrack’s from a previous relationship.

    The town argues that they’re not a family. Where are all those “parental rights” folks now?

    4 Responses to “THAT DAMN ACLU”


    Comment by
    Daryl Cobranchi
    August 11th, 2006
    at 4:45 pm

    Well, if the definition of family requires that everyone has to be related to everyone else by blood or marriage, half the folks in my town would be in trouble.

    True story (WARNING! WARNING! ANECDOTE AHEAD!): Years ao in DE when our youngest (now 7) was just a baby, there was a young girl, age maybe 12, who lived down the street. This girl had a very complicated family life. Her mom and her current stepfather had each been married three times and had kids from each marriage. ( I’m not sure we ever really figured out all the relationships.) She was visiting Lydia and the baby when she innocently asked if all four kids had the same father. Assured that they do, she was shocked. She’d never known anyone to stay married or together long enough to have four kids. A marriage that had lasted 13 years was equally unheard of.

    Lydia and I just celebrated 20 on Wednesday. I wonder what she’d say now.


    Comment by
    JJ Ross
    August 11th, 2006
    at 11:23 pm

    Jodi asks-
    since when does the government have the right to issue permits for people to live in their own home?

    JJ exclaims –
    you’re kidding, right?


    Comment by
    Daryl Cobranchi
    August 12th, 2006
    at 3:59 pm

    Except in college towns, these ordinances tend to be aimed at poor minorities who share a house or apartment to cut down on expenses. The laws are transparently racist.

    Of course, the law could also ensnare two gays or lesbians with kids.


    Comment by
    Just passing by...
    August 13th, 2006
    at 12:40 am

    Gotta watch out for those right wing nuts trying to get home owner registries and communities like this organized. While communities zone, registries are more far reaching in that they ask if one is married, single, co-habitating single same sex, and co-habitating single opposite sex.

    Yikes, think of the problems that could arise from these registries and communities:

    ~Iin communities where married onlys are zoned in, selling a home at a fair price could be problematic for a non-married person as they try to move out of the community to be in compliance with the ordinance.

    ~If the registries are public, businesses could use them to hire people based on life style. Yeah, yeah, Constitution and all, but what really could stop employers from peeking in on people and basing qulaifications also on life style and risks associated?

    ~Married only zoned communities bring in married only businesses. Ack. Think of the implications for diversity of goods and market fairness. If these are found Constiitutionally sound for one group, it could spill over to a whole county or state.

    ~Regulating families so tightly leads could also lead to someone spouting off about education and lead the community to adopt a code for children of residents to attend a mandatory private or g-school based on only one style of family values.

    ~Married only communities might lean toward a pastor to be the HOA leader – which eerily makes me think of Hilldale and Colorado City.