EDUCATIONNEWS.ORG
Shills for the NEA? Here’s their blurb leading into an article on Teach for America:
Just because these graduates have math and science, does not mean they can teach the kids… 19,000 kids without jobs is what they got!!! Next year, not one school district will be ask, how many stayed in teaching. They will be recruiting again and again and cost the schools system about 2.6 billion a year for teacher turnover and Teach for America in 17 years have cost many districts an arm and a leg!!
For the record, Teach for America recruits some of the best and brightest, as the graphic below will attest.
These hardly seem like the kinds of folks who couldn’t find jobs. It seems pretty strange that educationnews.org would diss young people who want to dedicate a year or two of their lives to helping kids in the nation’s worst schools.
4 Responses to “EDUCATIONNEWS.ORG”
|
Comment by Jeanne June 18th, 2006 at 2:07 pm |
Oh dear, oh dear! TWO verb errors in just the one tiny paragraph. Surely that was not meant as a defense of teachers…. Reminds me of when my son’s 4th grade teacher sent home a spelling list she created in connection to their upcoming field trip to a facility near Charlotte where they would see hawks, eagles, and owls. The teacher had written at the top of the list, “The Rapture Center.” I sent the list back noting that I thought she meant The Raptor Center (a wonderful place, by the way), but that I thought the idea of a Rapture Center introduced some wonderful possibilities. Sigh. She didn’t get it. |
|
Comment by Daryl Cobranchi June 18th, 2006 at 4:14 pm |
Soylent Green is people! |
|
Comment by Natalie June 19th, 2006 at 2:46 am |
The commas! Does no one care about the commas? (I know I’m prone to the occasional sloppy error, but this is sad, sad, sad.) |
|
Comment by Dana June 19th, 2006 at 3:25 am |
hmmm, let’s see. The typical route for a TFA teacher (and that is how I got to be an elementary school teacher in a TX border town) is to enter the district and within two years earn some sort of teacher of the year award. In my district, they changed the teacher of the year qualifications to give the other teachers a chance (you had to teach for more than two years). TFA’s vision goes well beyond the classroom. Some stay in the class room, but that isn’t necessarily TFA’s central goal. It is only a short term solution to the education crisis. Their long term vision is: In the long run, we build a force of leaders with the insight and credibility that comes from having taught in a low-income community. They work from education and from every other sector to effect the fundamental changes needed to ensure that all children have an equal chance in life. And as to districts “wasting” money on these students who, for the most part, could make twice what they make as teachers but have chosen to forgo that opportunity for a time, they get a pretty good return on their money…a lot more than the other methods of filling these positions. And you should try out their summer institute. I learned more in those six weeks than I did in all my education programs leading to my degree in secondary education. Partially because it wasn’t so theoretical. We didn’t spend a semester talking about Piaget. We talked about theory, practial application, and lead our own classes in the morning where a team of supervisors watched and provided feedback….not to mention the follow-up support once you are placed, monthly meetings, required observations of master teachers, and occasional drop-ins from experienced teachers to give feedback. Principals are happy with their TFA hires and report they are of superior quality to other new teacher hires…even if most of them do only stick around for two years. |
